Do You Know Who Coined the Phrase? 'Give Me a One-Handed Economist!'
Explore the fascinating origins and evolution of the phrase 'Give me a one-handed economist!', often used to critique professionals for their contradictory advice.
3 min read
Based on the article "The Elusive One-Handed Professional: A Journey Through the Origins of a Famous Expression", this post examines the origins of the commonly cited expression about a "one-handed" or "one-armed" professional, often attributed to economists, lawyers, and other experts. The phrase critiques the tendency of these professionals to provide advice laden with caveats—frequently hedging their suggestions with "on the one hand… on the other hand."
US President Harry Truman (1945–1953) is famously credited with exclaiming, “Give me a one-handed economist! All my economists say, ‘On the one hand… [and then] on the other.’” Frustrated with indecisive counsel, Truman longed for straightforward advice instead of endless deliberations.
Early Appearances
The earliest recorded version of this expression dates back to 1936, predating Truman’s presidency. It was used to criticize a political platform’s contradictory positions, calling for a "one-armed platform writer." Over the ensuing decades, variations of the expression reappeared in different contexts, often referencing tax experts, lawyers, and economists.
Attribution to Truman
Although the saying is often associated with President Truman, concrete evidence linking him to the quote remains elusive. The earliest mention attributing the phrase to Truman appeared in 1974, decades after he left office. It described an alleged interaction with his advisor, Edwin Nourse. Subsequent similar accounts emerged, but their delayed documentation raises doubts about their reliability.
Evolution of the Expression
While the essence of the expression has remained consistent—expressing a desire for clear and decisive guidance—the specific professions and wording have evolved over time. This adaptability underscores its enduring relevance and widespread appeal.
What Do You Think?
Does this expression still resonate in today’s fast-paced world? Have you encountered similar frustrations with ambiguous advice?
Source:
Enjoyed this post? Found it helpful? Feel free to leave a comment below to share your thoughts or ask questions. A GitHub account is required to join the discussion.
